What is the dark night of the soul?

Question

Accepted Answer

The dark night of the soul, a term from the 16th-century Spanish mystic St. John of the Cross, describes the experience of spiritual desolation, meaninglessness, and felt absence of God or transcendence that many spiritual practitioners describe as a necessary passage in deepening spiritual development. In contemporary contexts, it has been extended to describe any profound experience of existential disorientation, loss of meaning, and dissolution of previous identity structures that precedes genuine transformation. St. John of the Cross wrote Noche Oscura del Alma (Dark Night of the Soul) describing the stages of spiritual development in the Carmelite tradition. He identified two forms: the passive dark night of the senses (in which the pleasures and consolations that sustained spiritual practice are withdrawn, leaving the practitioner in apparent spiritual aridity) and the more profound passive dark night of the spirit (in which the practitioner's most fundamental concepts and experiences of God are dissolved, leaving apparent emptiness). Both, he proposed, are purifications rather than abandonments. Contemporary psychology has engaged the dark night concept in several ways. Dr. Gerald May at the Shalem Institute for Spiritual Formation, in his book The Dark Night of the Soul: A Psychiatrist Explores the Connection Between Darkness and Spiritual Growth, examined the overlap between dark night experiences and psychological depression, proposing that while they share symptoms, they differ in their relationship to meaning: depression is an illness that typically involves felt loss of self and meaning without redemptive quality, while the dark night involves the loss of a previous self and meaning system that is, in retrospect, experienced as part of genuine growth. The phenomenology of dark night experiences commonly includes: loss of the sense of God's presence, loss of meaning in previously meaningful practices, disorientation about one's fundamental beliefs and identity, a sense of being abandoned, and an inability to find comfort in the resources that previously supported one. What distinguishes this from ordinary spiritual difficulty is its depth and duration, and the specific quality of the loss: not only is the practice not working, but the entire framework within which the practice made sense has dissolved. From a psychological integration standpoint, dark night experiences often mark significant developmental transitions: the dissolution of an ego structure or identity that has become too small for the person's actual development. The grief of this dissolution is real, and the disorientation is genuine. What the tradition suggests, and what many practitioners report retrospectively, is that the experience points toward a more authentic and less defended relationship with self, with others, and with ultimate reality than was available before the dissolution.